Shuttle Spacewalker HOT-663 Slot 1 Motherboard Reviewed by Vijay Anand (28/3/99)
<Introduction><The Good><The Bad><Conclusion><Rating> IntroductionEver wondered where someone sells Shuttle motherboards locally?
Well, after reading many on-line reviews about them... I'm in the same group! A good
reason why Shuttle is a rarity here could be because it's former partner IPC, is really
'down' these days compared to a few years back when IPC held roadshows and many other
advertising schemes. Also, Shuttle is concentrating it's efforts in some other countries,
not particularly in this region. This Shuttle board was flown in from Taiwan (their
headquarters) and whether it'll sell in Singapore or not is questionable, but for now,
we'll evaluate this board. Notice the title? With a name like "Shuttle
Spacewalker", you would think that you're getting cutting-edge technology on-board!
Whether you notice the name or not, their box design will make you notice it! (very
unfortunately that my Dad's DV-camera is not available for me take a snap). We'll see if
the board lives up to it's name. The GoodThe board comes in an older 4/3/1(PCI/ISA/AGP) expansion slot configuration but Shuttle has thoughtfully put 4-DIMMS to accommodate up to 1Gb of ram. Now, how many boards that you know come in a 4/3/1 config and equipped with 4 DIMMS? The best part is the location of HDD, FDD, ATX P/S and the 4 DIMM slots are placed right up-front. This confirms with th ATX spec 2.0 and the real benefit comes from the ease of installation and improved ventilation. The various LED & all other connectors are clearly labeled and located to the right of the board. This would be better if placed in front. The board includes a green-coloured heatsink over the 440BX chipset. This helps to get rid of heat from the BX chipset better while running at higher speeds & is even better if one is overclocking the board (that is if you can!). Cooling is plenty, more than other boards I've seen to date! There are FOUR 3-pin power connectors for CPU, Chassis, AGP fan installation & miscellaneous. Not bad for a board that has trouble overclocking! Should you need the SB-link connector for some PCI sound-cards, you'll be excited(that is if you have pure-DOS games like Crusader) to know that one is provided, although the Creative PCI sound-cards(which the SB-link was 1st intended for usage) are engineered in a different way that you don't require this connector to get full DOS sound support. Other cards like the wonderful Yamaha Waveforce 192XG uses this connector for pure DOS support too. For setting the FSB speed & the multiplier control, you have
the choice of the old fashioned jumpers or the menu in the BIOS. Seems odd at first but it
came in handy. The case was when I was using the the Bios controlled settings for the FSB
and CPU-Speed, then I selected an FSB too high, then the PC hung. I used the jumper-based
setup to start the CPU at it's default speed and it worked! So this gave me 100%
confirmation that I clocked the chip too high. I shorted the CMOS-clear pins and I was
ready to use the BIOS to configure my FSB and CPU speed easily again. There is a large
fixed jumper block (4x2) that controls the use of a jumper-based or BIOS controlled
cpu-setup. For manual CPU setup, there are printed tables to refer on the motherboard
itself. The beautiful Shuttle CD comes with these software for the
motherboard: System Manager, Adobe Acrobat Reader 2.1 for the complete manual. Here are a
few snaps I've taken for the install screen and the System-Manager(SM) utility:
The System manager is quite a nifty program! Not only does it monitor your CPU temp but it also helps to monitor your HDD-disk space, Virtual Memory space, set alerts for all, give detailed info on all your expansion slots and ram. These screen-shots were take when running the HOT-681 socket-370 motherboard, therefore the info/values on the Splash-Screen image and the Ram-info image are not reflecting this Slot-1 board. Speaking of monitoring, the CPU temp sensor well touches the heatsink of the CPU, so you can get quite an accurate read-out. Shuttle motherboard come with an installation/features fold-out only. The 'Complete' Manual is on the CD! And I must say that information and diagrams are well detailed on the manual found in the CD. Not to forget is that this board has an on-board Yamaha XG YMF724F-V chipset. If some of you are thinking of a quick and easy way of getting sound while changing to this board and pairing it with an el-cheapo pair of speakers.. forget it! You'll need amplified self-powered speakers as all of these on-board sound-chipsets don't have any amplification circuits, only pure line-out for the audio signal. Sound was very decent when hooked up with my Altec Lansing ACS400 speakers but I found that I had to set the volume quite high to hear sounds well, even the volume slider is high in windows. So don't expect any room filling sound.. just something to satisfy general users who sit in front of the PC. Depending on what games or music your listening to, the 3D sound in the volume properties can give you a nice effect.
|
The Test
The processors used for my test is the C-300A slot-1 which is of the SL2WM batch that has been tested to run at 450 or above and the P3-500. Yep! You read it right! I had a P3-500 to play with for a week. It's of the SL3CD batch and is overclockable too! With such a good rig to play with I was let down by the Diamond Fusion Z100 which refused to do 83Mhz and was flaky at 75Mhz bus. It runs exceptionally at 66Mhz or 100Mhz bus. This is due to the already overclocked Diamond video card, its chipset clock and ram clock are set higher than other Banshees. Hmm.. a price to pay for an overclocked card.
Test Configuration |
|
Processor(s): | Pentium III - 500 Retail,
batch=SL3CD, 2.0V, Malay, Pack Date = 13/2/99 Celeron - 300A Retail, batch=SL2WM, 2.0V, Malay |
RAM: | 1 - 64MB Hitachi 8ns PC100 SDRAM DIMM |
Hard Drive(s): | IBM Deskstar-3 3.2G |
Video Card(s): | Diamond Fusion Z100 AGP, 16MB SGRAM |
Bus Master Drivers: | Windows 98 Bus Mastering Drivers |
Video Drivers: | 3Dfx Voodoo Banshee Reference drivers ver: 4.11.01.0378-1.00 from kit ver: 1.02.03 |
Operation System(s): | Windows 98 (build 4.10.1998) |
Area Tested | C-300A (66x4.5) |
C-450 (100x4.5) |
P3-500 (100x5) |
P3-515 (103x5) |
P3-525 (105x5) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
CPU Integer (MIPS) | 878.0484 | 0 | 1464.842 | 1505.867 | 1535.027 |
CPU Floating Point (MFLOPS) | 349.6542 | 0 | 583.588 | 599.7007 | 611.8404 |
Video(2D) (MPixeles/s) | 83.14175 | 0 | 123.7426 | 128.0133 | 130.2955 |
Direct3D (MPixeles/s) | 190.937 | 0 | 198.135 | 199.4132 | 199.6869 |
OpenGL (MPixels/s) | 7.695069 | 0 | 12.54615 | 13.03555 | 13.3108 |
Memory (MB/s) | 516.8631 | 0 | 819.7101 | 862.6664 | 883.4947 |
Cached Disk (MB/s) | 54.10983 | 0 | 86.14954 | 98.84568 | 99.49705 |
Uncached Disk (MB/s) | 1.955576 | 0 | 1.979477 | 1.971813 | 1.66658 |
Integer | 70 | 0 | 121 | 125 | 129 |
FPU | 74 | 0 | 120 | 123 | 126 |
MMX | 69 | 0 | 120 | 125 | 128 |
*Take note that the low OpenGL scores are due to the lack of a full OpenGL-ICD for the Banshee cards. Till now, only a mini-GL driver is available for selected games. Noticed that the celeron when overclocked to 450, the score is zero? Well that's because this board won't even show the boot screen!!! In many other boards, this C-300A runs at 450 without any additional voltage increases. Even it has difficulty in overclocking the P3. In another motherboard with a TNT,it can do 600Mhz! This one dislikes to budge from it's default marked specifications.
CPU | NU Sys Info (pts) | Sisoft CPU benchmark (MIPS) |
Sisoft FPU benchmark (MFLOPS) |
Sisoft memory benchmark (MB/s) |
C-300A (66 x 4.5) | 94.1 | 718 | 180 | 124 |
C-450 (100 x 4.5) | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
P3-500 (100 x 5) | 230 | 1193 | 302 | 185 |
P-515 (103 x 5) | 245.9 | 1226 | 310 | 191 |
525MHz (105 x 5) | 246.8 | 1250 | 317 | 195 |
You would have guessed by now, from my earlier hints/prompts that the worst complaint would be that it can't overclock the CPU stable enough, even if the same CPU has been overclocked many times in other boards. The motherboard diagram in the installation fold-out showed that this same board but with more capacitors. Looking at my actual board at hand, it seems that there are markings to hold more capacitors as shown in the diagram. This could be 1 reason for it's bad overclocking but who knows if the board itself isn't well done in the first place? Just looking at the board gives away no clues. It has a very good list of FSB options avialbe but what a waste. Now I'm wondering if this board can really support 4 DIMMs of SDRAM stably! Too bad, I don't have more than 2 sticks of SDRAM to try it put.
Another complaint that's as bad as the above one is the positioning of many connectors. Truly, this is the first motherboard(along with the HOT-681) I'm encountering with atrocious locations of connectors!! I've seen no-name brands do better than that. The main casing connectors, HDD, FDD and P/S connectors are placed excellently. In contrast are the KB & mouse Power-on-settings, Fan, CD/video/AUX-in, WOL, IrDA and SB-Link connectors. Took a guess where they are located? Yes/No? Whatever.. they are located IN-BETWEEN PCI/AGP SLOTS, BEHIND THE PCI SLOTS and BEHIND THE SLOT-1 CONNECTOR!!! First thing, it's a pain in the neck to connect these connectors while starting from scratch.. imagine how and where the cables will run. Secondly, it's a ROYAL PAIN to even think about connecting or disconnecting some of these connectors when your whole system is completely setup! Eventhough these are less used items, they are still located in very very odd places. You would have to unscrew and pluck out a few cards to access these connectors. Fortunately, things like the CPU/FSB jumper controls, battery and CMOS discharge/clear jumpers are located up-front.
Other quibbles would be the low sound-output of this particular YAMAHA chipset and the self-connected cpu-stands (some others like AOpen, MSI have it fixed already). The ATX connector can be placed a bit more to the corner front of the motherboard, so as to have more space while installing rams. Finally, all of us would prefer a 5th PCI slot.
Conclusion
Overall, it's a vey good board that does it's job well, has got good software, decent on-board sound, 4 DIMM slots for ram expansion but was really let down due to it's inability in overcloking properly, eventhough alomst all the settings and stuff needed for overclocking are available. Just don't expect to overclock your CPU with this board.
MOTHERBOARD RATING
Overall Rating (Out of a maximum of 5 Star) |
|
Installation | ****1/2 |
Performance | **** |
Price | N/A |
Overclockability | **1/2 |
Material Quality | **** |
Stability | **** |
Overall Rating | *** 3/4 |
Copyright © 1998 by Singapore Hardware Zone. All rights reserved.
None of the above
shall be reproduced, copied and/or
modified without the permission of the WebMaster.