Singapore Hardware Zone

IBM DeskStar 14GXP

CREATIVE FPS 2000

Four Point Surround Sound

Reviewed by Anurax Lian (10/06/99)

FPS 2000 Specifications

Satellite Speakers

Four 2.75" compact satellite speakers with 14 total RMS watts at 10% THD per channel

Satellite dimensions

3.5" X 3.5" X 3.5" with 2.5" long throw driver

Sub Woofer

Powered subwoofer with level control included with 25 RMS watts at 10% THD

Sub Woofer Dimensions

14.1" X 8.0" X 6.5" with 5.25" woofer

Frequency Range

50Hz - 20kHz

Controls

Remote in-line, master volume control can be attached to the computer monitor or other convenient locations.

Speaker Stands

One pair of 21-inch speaker stands

Cables

Two 9-foot (3m) front satellite cables

Two 16-foot (5m) rear satellite cables

With sticker labels for easy identification

Power Supply

AC/DC adapter included

Safety and EMI compliance

UL, cUL, CE etc

Price

S$ 320 (EST)

<Introduction><The Good><Installation>
<The Bad> <Conclusion><Rating>

Back to top


Introduction

Ever since Creative Labs merged with Henry Kloss' Cambridge Sound System to manufacture PC speakers, they have since been releasing more powerful speakers for the PC. Their initial releases (e.g. SBS 20) were never the type of speakers that games and music enthusiasts wanted. When PC works first came out, people generally compared it with Altec Lansing ACS45/44 series. Many would agree the Bass was pretty good but sound was too low and the ACS45 was still the preferred choice to many. The Four Point Surround Sound System was generally a cheap gimmick, which many never actually fell for and Creative probably felt the pinch and seriously needed something to kick off their four-speaker configuration. The other 2 speaker the MicroWorks and SoundWorks were only 2 speaker 1 Subwoofer configuration, both were excellent speakers, especially the MicroWorks but never really found a niche in the gaming/home user world. The Desktop Theater 5.1 had some pretty good features like AC3 support but most of its speaker/sub came from the PC works family and therefore was not in a class of its own even though the price was otherwise.

This time round Creative came out with something pretty outstanding if I should say so myself. THE Four Point Surround Sound 2000 Digital. I would generally say this is THE set of speaker to pair up with the Sound Blaster Live. It is a digital speaker that accepts signals from a 9 pin digital DIN (not AC3 SPDIF cable) from the digital I/O card. (Finally got to use the Digital card from my SBLive ... whew no waste). However, if you are using the SBLive Value, Monster Sound MX300 or even a 16Bit sound card, you may still use the analog inputs on the FPS 2000. If your sound card supports 4 speaker configuration, that's great, but however if it does not, well not to worry as the FPS 2000 will split the signal from the front to rear, meaning you'll have 2 left and 2 right speakers.

The satellite speaker from the FPS2000 are fantastic, they are the same type of speakers the Desktop Theater 5.1 used for the front. The PC Works , FPS 1000 and the Desktop Theater 5.1 uses even smaller satellite speaker. As for the Subwoofer, the FPS 2000 comes with a pretty big Subwoofer at 14" driving at 25 watts compared to the others driving at only 8 - 10 watts. Obviously the FPS 2000 is technically more powerful than the others (with exception to the MicroWorks). Another cool thing about it is that it's Black in color and not the Plain-Jane white we see so often. Anyway so much for its physical appearance. Let's see how this baby rocks.

Back to top


The Good

Features & Benefits

FourPointSurround FPS2000 Digital consists of four 3"-wide satellite speaker cubes, plus a compact, floor-standing subwoofer cabinet. The four compact satellites create realistic four-channel positional audio while the subwoofer can be positioned on the floor -- behind your TV, under your desk, or behind furnitures, out of the way, for best bass response.

Possible placement solutions would be

A - Placing the rear speakers on the left and right side of the wall.

B - Placing the rear speakers behind the user

C - Placing the rear speaker at the edge of a wide table while front speaker next to the monitor

D - Place the rear speaker below the table top at each side

Note: The satellite speakers are magnetically shielded so it will not cause any interference with other electronic device e.g. monitor. However, the Sub Woofer is not and it is advisable to place it further away from other electronic devices, to prevent magnetic interference.

The FourPointSurround FPS2000 Digital system delivers a carefully fine-tuned stereo sound system, usually produced by expensive home surround stereo systems. It is best suited for the computer PC environment with a small surrounding. 2 top areas where these speakers really impressed me were in the games and movie testing. They not only sounded good, they actually sound life like.

I ran up a few movies to check out the quality of the speaker. Running the take off scene from Top Gun sounded superb. I jack the volume all the way to 100% and there was simply no distortion and the quality of the sound was still sharp, clear and crisp. (Note the max volume out of my DVD/VCD encoder card was set at 86% though). Explosions and other sound effects were just as good. The sound driven out from the satellite speaker was very impressive. The Sub Woofer was pretty strong too; anyone within a 5m radius can probably feel the impact coming from the woofer. The sound got even better when I ran my DVD movies. It was exceptionally clear, crisp and sharp.

Many would say that AC3 support should be added in, but to me it is quite redundant. AC3/THX sound system are great when played for a large audience in a large theater, but when you are in a room by yourself or with a couple of friends, such a system is unnoticeable. Since the FPS200 was meant for a small enclosed area, it need not provide such feature. Allowing the SBLive Liveware 2.0 to set the environment will be more than adequate.

I tested the FPS2000 playing Unreal with EAX enable. Unreal is probably one of the best games for testing out your speakers as it sports a lot of features. While playing the game, I deliberately lower the background music to concentrate more on the movement sound. The life likeness of the sound was probably due to my SBLive but the fact that the FPS2000 was able to deliver top clarity audio really impressed me. Each footstep and movement felt like they were coming from different directions and one could easily know where it is coming from. The rear speaker actually added more atmosphere to the game than ever before. Previously, I was using a Pioneer Dolby Digital Home Entertainment Sound System with a 5 set Philip speaker system along with a Yamaha 25-Watt Sub Woofer. Even though this setup costs more than $800, it was unable to deliver such realism to the game ambience which the FPS200 could. In Need For Speed 3, the engines and screeching sound from the tires were easily heard and the direction of the sound was easily identifiable. The FPS 2000 with a SBLive card and a game that supports EAX is truly wonderful.

Aureal could probably gang up with Altec Lansing to give Creative a run for its money but for now I can certainly say that this is the best 3D Sound Solution currently available.

Back to top


Installation

Take advantage of the clear, distortion-free audio by connecting the Digital DIN output of your FourPointSurround FPS2000 Digital speakers to the Sound Blaster Live! Digital I/O card.

Just follow these simple steps to unleash the full effect of your digital speakers:

 

1.

Insert one end of the SPDIF cable into the DIGITAL DIN output jack on the Sound Blaster Live! Digital I/O card. The Digital DIN connector is the only connector with the 9-pin configuration.

Note: The actual position of the Digital I/O card may differ slightly from this diagram

2.

Insert the other end of the SPDIF cable into the DIGITAL DIN input on the subwoofer.

3.

Complete the following steps:

  • Position your mouse at the top of your screen to activate Creative's Sound Blaster Live!
  • Launcher
    Select "Audio HQ"
    On the Configuration tabbed page, select the option "4 Speakers"
  • A sofa icon (representing you) appears in the center of the "Preview Box", with four speakers at the corners of the box.

That's it! You are now ready to experience 3D digital audio like never before.

Note: FourPointSurround FPS2000 Digital will detect the presence of a plug connected to the DIGITAL DIN input and give the DIGITAL DIN input priority. Any signal present at the AUDIO INPUT will be ignored. Be sure to remove the plug from the DIGITAL DIN INPUT if you wish to listen to a sound source through the analog AUDIO INPUT.

The Sub woofer is pretty big compared to other sub-woofers from Creative. It is made of Solid wood. This is great as the resonance that the wood produces is very warm and one actually feels it rather than hears it. Plastic generally generates vibration, which sound very cheap. If you'd notice the yellow label on the sub woofer, it is a heat hazard warning. There are heat sinks for the speakers but running them at about 85% - 75% loud for more than 4 hours playing Star Wars the heat generated was so low that I did not even notice. (Note: The room was Air Conditioned at 23 degree Celsius)

The position of the sub woofer was below my table just behind a wall. It is important to note where to position the sub woofer so as to achieve optimal sound. In fact, incorrect placement can lead to annoying sound. I once saw a joker place the sub woofer of his ACS45 on the top shelf of his Sitoca computer table, he kept complaining of headaches. Thank God Sitoca builds solid table or his table would be shaking every time there is sound. Anyway, I quickly placed it on the floor for him and he immediately heard the difference. A good position to place the sub woofer is on the floor with nothing beneath it and its behind facing a solid wall. The wall will provide a reflecting effect that really enhances the feel of the bass. Do not crowd anything around the speaker, as this would affect the sound.

Above is the external volume controller where you can adjust the balance for the Front and Rear speakers. This is pretty useful if your speakers are situated too far apart. Many people will face the problem of not being able to place the rear speakers closer than they want to. Now, all you have to do is adjust the balance more to the rear to accommodate for the lost sound.

Back to top


The Bad

Well I can't think of many bad things about this set of speaker. It's Good ... real good in fact. However there are a couple of things I'd like to mention is that the speakers are meant for PCs inside a room. They don't sound that great in a large open area. When I was at A-Zone and heard the display set I was not that impressed with it, as the surrounding area was pretty huge. However, after bringing it home, man, did my impression change. However, I'd like to note that the even though the Sub Woofer was about 1.5 times more powerful than the PC Works, FPS 1000 and the Desktop 5.1, it could have been better. I feel that at times the feeling is not strong enough unless you adjust the Sub-Woofer volume. Ah yes, not to mention the volume control for the sub woofer volume control is located at the side of the Woofer where all the cables are connected too. It is a real pain in the butt (actually pain in the head) as I kept hitting my head on the table top to reach the control. They should have place the volume control on the remote volume control stick too. Overall, most would find that the sub woofer would be more than sufficient.

Another thing that disappointed me was the lack of an equalizer control. The Desktop 5.1 had some pretty nifty external box controls while the FPS 2000 had only a volume and Front/Rear balance control. It would be great if Creative could add a Treble, Bass and other controls to the external controller.

Back to top


Conclusion

This is really a good set of speakers for the PC, if not one of the finest. It carries good sound and provide good warm bass while still maintaining the quality and clarity of the output. It's fantastic for games and watching movies off your PC in a room. For the price of slightly over $300, it is well worth every cent spent. If you have the budget for it then go for it especially if you own the Sound Blaster Live.

Back to top


Ratings

Overall Rating (Out of a maximum of 5 Star)

Installation ****
Performance ****½
Price (OEM Value) *****
Price (Retail Full) ****
Innovation *****
Life Span *****
Software Bundle ****½
Material Quality ****½
Overall Rating ****½

Back to top


Copyright © 1999 by Singapore Hardware Zone. All rights reserved.

None of the above shall be reproduced, copied and/or
modified without the permission of the WebMaster.